Researchers Bust Antibacterial Spider Silk Myth
(Photo: Michael Podger/Unsplash)Spider silk has long been said to have antibacterial properties. The ancient Greeks and Romans supposedly used the silk when treating flesh wounds, and some recent studies report antimicrobial activity (AMA) on spider silk, leading many cultures and social circles today to believe the sticky substance is a worthwhile replacement for advanced antibacterial medicines. But researchers at Aarhus University in Denmark have found the opposite to be true; spider silk appears to have no antibacterial properties whatsoever, even when examining silk from multiple spider species.
In their study published Tuesday, researchers Simon Fruergaard, Marie Braad Lund, Andreas Schramm, Thomas Vosegaard, and Trine Bilde report having looked for AMA across seven types of spider silk, accounting for differences within the spider phylogeny. They tested for antimicrobial effects against Escherichia coli (better known as E. coli), Pseudomonas putida (sometimes associated with skin infections), and Bacillus subtilis (a benign form of bacteria that doesn’t actually harm humans or animals). Using direct contact assays (in which untreated silk is tested against antibiotic susceptibility) and disc diffusion assays (in which silk extracts are tested against the same), the team was able to conclude that all three types of bacteria were unthreatened by the silk.
“We were unable to detect the antimicrobial activity of social spider silk, and this made us curious about why other studies were able to detect antimicrobial activity in spider silk. We then started scrutinizing the papers reporting antimicrobial activity in every detail, and became aware of methodological shortcomings,” Tilde said to Gizmodo about the research. A more realistic application of “spider silk” on wounds would involve a spider-inspired synthetic silk developed in the UK a few years back. The synthetic material may someday be used to deliver drugs and close wounds with less risk of infection.
Spider silk is still incredibly resilient, though. “Spider silk is renowned for its extraordinary physical properties such as high tensile strength and flexibility,” the study reads. “Silk is used as an anchor for rapid escape, a snare for prey capture, to immobilize cannibalistic mates, to make egg cases for protection . . . and even in silk diving bells that facilitate underwater life.” Based on the silk’s wide range of uses and overall durability, it made sense to the researchers at first that it may also protect itself by way of killing off bacteria. Unfortunately, that just isn’t the case.
Comments are closed.